I was busily working away this evening on getting some final grades knocked out for my students when an e-mail appeared from one of my players. He has been reading through the 4e PHB for the better part of a week now and here are his ‘comments’. In an attempt to keep it clean here I have edited only for language. I think the feeling still comes through however.
Has anyone been reading the 4th players handbook? I realize I have more time than most, but I’m getting to the point where I don’t really care for the system. Correction, actually I’ve gotten to the point where I think this system is @#!#*. First, in reading through the upper level powers there’s no "WOW" factor. It just seems like more of the same. Kinda boring. Second, I don`t care for the skill system. There`s no points, just trained or not trained. If your trained you get +5 on the skill check. Big whoop! A rogue who constantly picks pockets is only 5 points better than a fighter of the same level. Yes, you can skill focus it, but so can the fighter, and if the fighter spends an extra feat for skill training in thievery, he can now pick locks, disable device, sleight of hands and pick pockets just as well as any thief thats been doing it for his entire career. Don`t like it at all.
Here`s the one that really kills me. At 8th level a cleric can cast the ritual raise dead. So can any other class just by spending a few feats. REALLY? How can you possibly justify a fighter who doesn’t have a relationship with a certain diety being able to raise the dead because he spent two feats? What ever happened to "Oh no our friend just died, we have to find a cleric, and probably do some service for his church, to get the pinacle of divine magic. Bringing someone back from the dead. No wait, Bob the drunken 8th level janitor spent a few feats, he’ll do it for a bottle of bourbon." @#$%! really?
4th edition makes 1st level really cool. I agree. Everyone always has something to do. OK. But no one has their niche anymore. I personally like the specialized character that cowers in a fight. What about the pacifist wizard with divination. Where’s the @#%$! gnome illusionist? Oh, next years book? OK.
I think perhaps one of our group is heading firmly towards grognard territory. Hmm, wonder where I downloaded that Pathfinder RPG file to?……
Tags: 4e D&D

1 comment
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link
http://www.demolitionink.com/wordpress/wp-trackback.php?p=26
June 3, 2008 at 9:59 am
greywulf
I’m with your player, all the way. 4th Edition D&D is, to put it mildly, pure unmitigated crap. Which is a shame, because there are a few good things in there too, if you dig deeply enough.
For example, the minions rules rock, the first Chapter is good and I like the presentation of the races. From there, it’s downhill all the way.
Too much focus on combat, too little variety in the Powers, too few Powers to allow customizable characters, and…. well. Let’s just say I’m not a fan, at all.